AB 5 is a California law that codifies the ABC test for worker classification, which requires workers to meet specific criteria to be classified as independent contractors. It has been controversial because it effectively bans the traditional leased owner-operator model in industries such as trucking. AB 5 in my opinion is nothing short of California’s attempt to outlaw the use of independent contractors in California and negatively impacts many instate businesses from effectively competing with out of state business that are free to use independent contractors and thus should be challenged on federal constitutional grounds.
In March of 2024, a California court denied the trucking industry’s attempt to block the application of AB 5. Despite opposition from industry groups, the judge emphasized that concerns about AB 5 should be addressed through legislative means rather than judicial intervention. So much for checks and balances in California! The legislature and the taxing authorities and now the courts exist for one purpose and one purpose only… to drive as many residents out of the state as possible.
Get help from our Dual-Licensed Tax Lawyers & CPAs at the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing by dialing (800) 681-1295 or click here to schedule a reduced rate initial consultation online.
Court Ruling on AB 5 and Trucking Industry
In a recent development, a California judge has delivered a significant ruling concerning the application of AB 5, a law governing independent contractor classification. AB 5 has been in effect since January 2020, drawing considerable opposition from the trucking industry due to its impact on the traditional leased owner-operator model.
Judge’s Decision
California District Judge Roger Benitez denied the trucking industry’s request for an injunction, emphasizing that the matter should be addressed through legislative channels rather than judicial intervention. This decision comes after previous legal battles and a preliminary injunction that was later reversed by the Court of Appeals. This decision makes absolutely no sense in that an overreaching legislature that writes an unconstitutional law is not likely to reverse that position without judicial intervention. So… Don’t expect justice in California! Welcome to the people’s republic of California where the state has an unquenching thirst for tax revenue and will trample anyone’s rights to get at it! Where a gallon of gas will cost you $2 more per gallon that almost anywhere in the nation and you are powerless to reason with them.
AB 5 and the ABC Test
Under AB 5, workers must satisfy all three prongs of the ABC test to qualify as independent contractors. Of particular concern for the trucking industry is the “B” prong, which requires that the worker’s tasks be outside the usual course of the company’s business which makes it a basic impossibility for any business in California to use subcontractors.
Legal Arguments
The California Trucking Association (CTA) and the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) raised multiple legal arguments, including preemption by federal law, violations of constitutional clauses, and implications for interstate commerce. However, Judge Benitez ruled against these claims, stating that AB 5 does not violate core constitutional principles or discriminate against interstate commerce. The U.S. Supreme court needs to be approached to potentially get justice here.
Implications and Next Steps
While CTA and OOIDA have expressed disagreement with the ruling and are considering options for appeal, Benitez emphasized that addressing the complexities of AB 5 should be pursued through political and economic avenues rather than California judicial intervention effectively robbing the trucking industry of justice given that federal intervention and California legislative intervention are highly unlikely.
What is the “ABC Test” for Worker Classification?
The ABC test for worker classification is a legal standard used to determine whether a worker should be classified as an employee or an independent contractor.
This test consists of three prongs, each of which a worker must satisfy to be classified as an independent contractor. The “A” prong evaluates whether the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity, both in terms of performance and the manner in which the work is carried out. The “B” prong assesses whether the worker’s tasks are outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business. Finally, the “C” prong examines whether the worker is engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed for the hiring entity. Meeting all three prongs of the ABC test typically indicates independent contractor status, while failing to meet any prong suggests employee classification.
Examples of How AB 5 May Impact the Trucking Industry
In light of California’s AB 5 law and its impact on the trucking industry, businesses face a myriad of legal considerations and challenges. From navigating complex worker classification requirements to addressing compliance issues and potential litigation risks, understanding the legal implications of AB 5 is essential for trucking companies seeking to operate within the bounds of the law.
Operational Changes and Compliance Challenges
Trucking businesses may face operational changes and compliance challenges as they adapt to AB 5 requirements. Companies may need to restructure their business models, contracts, and employment practices to ensure compliance with the law, which could involve additional administrative burdens and costs.
Litigation Risks and Legal Disputes
AB 5’s impact on the trucking industry could also give rise to litigation risks and legal disputes. Trucking companies may face lawsuits and regulatory enforcement actions related to worker classification and compliance with AB 5, potentially resulting in costly legal proceedings, penalties, and reputational damage.
Industry Advocacy and Legislative Efforts
In response to AB 5, the trucking industry may engage in advocacy efforts and legislative initiatives to seek exemptions, amendments, or alternatives to the law. Legal challenges and lobbying efforts aimed at addressing the specific concerns of the trucking sector could shape future developments and regulatory changes in this area.
We Are Here for You
Regardless of your business or estate needs, the professionals at the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing are here for you. We are open for business and our team will help ensure that your business is too. Contact the Law Offices of David W. Klasing today to discuss your business with one of our professionals.
In addition to our fully staffed main office in downtown Irvine California, the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing has unstaffed (conference room only) California based satellite offices in Los Angeles, San Bernardino, Santa Barbara, Panorama City, Oxnard, San Diego, Bakersfield, San Jose, San Francisco, Oakland, Carlsbad, Sacramento. We also have unstaffed (conference room only) satellite offices in Las Vegas Nevada, Salt Lake City Utah, Phoenix Arizona & Albuquerque New Mexico, Austin Texas, Washington DC, Miami Florida and New York New York that solely handle Federal & California Tax issues.
Our office technology allows clients to meet virtually via GoToMeeting. With end-to-end encryption, strong passwords, and top-rated reliability, no one is messing with your meeting. To schedule a reduced rate initial consultation via GoToMeeting follow this link. Call our office and request a GoToMeeting if you are an existing client. We also now offer a convenient scheduling option, where you can secure David W. Klasing, Esq M.S.-Tax CPA’s undivided attention for a 4-hour consultation at any of his satellite offices.
See our Employment Tax Law Q and A Library
