The withdrawals appeared on your bank statements. Employees received their paychecks. Your payroll company’s reports showed the tax calculations.
Then an IRS notice arrived saying your business never paid the employment taxes.
You may have funded every payroll in full and trusted the provider to handle the deposits. Discovering that someone diverted the money creates an immediate question: How do you prove what happened—and protect yourself when the IRS starts asking who was responsible?
The answer requires more than showing that money left your account. Your business’s tax obligations, your potential personal liability, and any criminal exposure involve different legal standards.
At the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing, our dual-licensed Civil and Criminal Tax Attorneys and CPAs can reconstruct the payroll transactions, investigate discrepancies, and defend you against unsupported allegations. We examine both the accounting evidence and the legal significance of what you knew, what you authorized, and how you responded.
A Recent Criminal Case Shows How the Money Can Disappear
In September 2026, Kansas bookkeeper Nicole Clem pleaded guilty to wire fraud and failure to pay employment taxes. According to the Justice Department, Clem withdrew money from clients’ bank accounts through ACH transfers for employment taxes or other taxes, then spent the funds on personal expenses. Investigators identified more than 20 clients with losses exceeding $1 million.
The Justice Department separately reported that Clem failed to pay employment taxes for her own business. Her case illustrates a critical point for employers: a withdrawal labeled for taxes does not establish that the government received the money.
A payroll provider may also conceal the problem through false returns. In another prosecution, Elite Payroll owner Matthew Brown charged clients for their full tax liabilities, substantially understated those liabilities on returns he filed with the IRS, and kept the difference. A federal court sentenced him to 50 months in prison in April 2025.
That possibility changes the investigation. Your records may show what the provider told you, while the IRS’s records show something entirely different.
Does Paying the Payroll Company Satisfy Your Tax Obligation?
Ordinarily, no. When a conventional payroll service provider or reporting agent fails to deposit employment taxes, the employer generally remains liable. Transferring the money to that provider does not itself constitute payment to the IRS. Authorizing a reporting agent through Form 8655 does not transfer the employer’s tax liability to the agent.
However, the precise arrangement matters. An authorized Section 3504 agent generally assumes liability alongside the employer for specified employment taxes. Different rules apply to an IRS-certified professional employer organization, or CPEO. Section 3511 generally treats a CPEO as the sole employer for federal employment tax purposes concerning remuneration it pays to qualifying worksite employees under a qualifying contract. That protection has statutory limits; a provider’s use of the term “PEO” does not establish it.
Our attorneys and CPAs review the service agreement, authorizations, certification status, relevant employees, and payment arrangements before accepting an assertion that your business owes a particular amount.
We also determine whether the problem involves missing deposits, false filings, incorrectly applied payments, or several issues at once. Each requires a different response.
Your Company’s Liability Does Not Automatically Establish Your Personal Liability
The IRS may investigate owners, officers, and other financial decision-makers for the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty, or TFRP, under Section 6672.
For payroll taxes, this civil penalty generally equals the unpaid employee income tax withholding and employee share of Social Security and Medicare taxes. The TFRP does not include the employer’s matching share of Social Security and Medicare taxes. The IRS must establish both responsibility and willfulness; ownership or an officer’s title alone does not resolve that analysis. Actual authority over financial decisions matters.
Outsourcing payroll does not automatically eliminate responsibility. But evidence that the provider deceived you can matter greatly to willfulness.
The IRS’s own guidance directs investigators to consider whether the provider concealed its noncompliance, whether the client knew about a pattern of missed payments, whether earlier IRS notices revealed problems, and what the client did after discovering the delinquencies.
That makes the chronology essential. When did you first receive reliable information that taxes remained unpaid? Did the provider send fabricated confirmations? Who received IRS correspondence? What steps did you take to verify or correct the problem?
Our team can organize those facts into a documented defense. We distinguish what you actually knew from what an investigator assumes you knew, and we examine whether the evidence supports the proposed penalty for each relevant period.
Could the Employer Face Criminal Tax Charges?
A payroll provider’s theft does not automatically make its customer a tax criminal.
Section 7202 allows prosecutors to charge a person who had the required tax duties and willfully failed to collect or truthfully account for and pay over the tax. A conviction can carry up to five years in prison per count. Criminal willfulness requires a voluntary, intentional violation of a known legal duty; the government must prove the offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
That differs from the civil TFRP standard, which can encompass reckless disregard and does not require an evil motive. A civil penalty determination does not itself establish criminal guilt.
The facts can nevertheless become more difficult if an employer discovers unpaid taxes and then knowingly submits false payroll returns, conceals records, or intentionally continues violating its tax obligations. What began as someone else’s wrongdoing does not excuse separate misconduct.
Our criminal tax defense analysis addresses your conduct independently of the provider’s. We examine the government’s potential theory, identify evidence that contradicts it, and advise you before you make substantive statements or submit explanations that could affect your position.
A criminal tax prosecution can threaten your freedom, business, professional standing, and family’s financial security. Early legal advice allows your defense to develop while records remain available and memories remain fresh.
Build the Evidence Before Relying on the Provider’s Explanation
A payroll company that has mishandled funds may promise to resolve everything next week. Meanwhile, your access to its portal could disappear, employees could leave, and electronic records could become harder to obtain.
Preserve the records your business can lawfully access, including:
- Bank statements, ACH details, and payroll funding authorizations.
- Payroll registers, tax calculations, and employee wage records.
- Forms 941, 940, W-2, and W-3, including versions the provider supplied.
- Deposit confirmations, service agreements, and IRS authorizations.
- IRS notices and communications with the provider, including assurances that it made payments.
Our CPAs can reconcile the wages, withholding, withdrawals, and government account records. Our attorneys can evaluate who controlled each step and what the discrepancies establish.
For deposits under your business’s employer identification number, the IRS recommends using independent EFTPS access to verify payments. Aggregate filing arrangements require a different reconciliation; a provider may properly report under its own EIN in certain circumstances. Our team identifies the appropriate records for your arrangement.
Preserve original files and their history. Do not backdate documents or change payroll records to make them match an explanation. Corrections should accurately document what happened.
An IRS Interview Deserves Preparation
The IRS may request a Form 4180 interview to investigate responsibility and willfulness for the TFRP. Questions can address financial authority, payment decisions, knowledge of unpaid taxes, and the payroll provider’s role. This interview concerns potential personal liability; it deserves more preparation than a routine bookkeeping discussion.
Our attorneys can prepare you using the actual records, represent you during the interview, and challenge inaccurate assumptions. We also assess whether the company and individual decision-makers have conflicting interests that require separate representation.
If the IRS proposes a TFRP assessment, its notice generally provides 60 days to appeal, or 75 days if it addresses the letter to you outside the United States. Prompt review helps preserve your opportunity to contest the proposal.
If IRS Criminal Investigation special agents contact you, seek criminal tax counsel before participating in a substantive interview. Do not lie, destroy records, or ignore compulsory legal process.
Put the Payroll Records and the Legal Defense Together by Contacting the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing
At the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing, our dual-licensed tax attorneys & CPAs can coordinate the work this situation demands: reconstructing transactions, assessing liability, addressing incorrect returns, preparing for IRS questioning, and defending against unsupported personal penalties or criminal allegations.
Where the evidence supports it, we can also request relief from applicable filing, payment, or deposit penalties. IRS guidance recognizes relevant factors in payroll-provider fraud cases, including timely funding, concealment, and prompt corrective action. Relief depends on the facts; the provider’s misconduct does not automatically erase penalties, and reasonable cause alone does not eliminate interest.
We can help document suspected provider misconduct through the appropriate channels. The IRS identifies Form 14157 as a way to report payroll service provider fraud involving tax deposits or returns. Making that report does not, by itself, resolve your business’s tax obligations or your individual exposure.
If your payroll company took the tax money but the IRS never received it, call the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing at (800) 681-1295 or contact us online HERE for a confidential, reduced-rate initial consultation.
You need a clear account of where the money went, what the provider filed, and what the law requires of you. Our dual-licensed attorneys and CPAs can bring those pieces together and build a response that protects your legal position.