Federal Courts Using Intended vs. Actual Tax Loss in Sentencing

Home » Law Blog » Federal Courts Using Intended Tax Loss, Rather Than “Actual” Tax Loss in Sentencing Tax Crimes

Table of Contents

Federal Courts Using Intended Tax Loss, rather than “Actual” Tax Loss in Sentencing Tax Crimes

If you intentionally evade your tax obligations, you can spend time in prison. Typically, your prison sentence will be determined by analyzing the amount of tax loss you caused the government to incur. Generally, defendants who create greater amounts of tax loss for the government will spend greater amounts of time in prison.

In the case of United States v. Upshur, the Third Circuit held that intended tax loss will be used in sentencing calculations for tax crimes instead of actual tax loss. The intended loss is the loss that would have occurred if the defendant had successfully evaded tax obligations.

For support with your tax issues, contact our Dual-Licensed Tax Attorneys & CPAs at the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing by dialing (800) 681-1295.

Third Circuit Issues Ruling on Sentencing Calculations for Tax Crimes

In May of 2023, the Third Circuit issued a ruling in the case of United States v. Upshur, establishing that intended tax loss will be used for tax crimes sentencing calculations, as opposed to actual tax loss. Intended tax loss refers to the financial loss the government would have sustained if a defendant’s tax crimes were successfully completed.

In Upshur, the defendant was indicted for perpetrating two fraudulent tax schemes over the course of a decade. First, Upshur told others that they could pay off their debts by wiring money to Upshur and allowing him to file tax forms stating that a trust he operated withheld substantial amounts of income tax on their behalf, hopefully resulting in substantial tax refunds. Upshur charged individuals $500 to join his scheme and an additional $250 for each debt they wished to pay off. However, this scheme was mostly unsuccessful. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) did issue a sizable refund for one participant in Upshur’s scheme, but the agency quickly identified its mistake and managed to freeze the payment.

In Upshur’s second scheme, he would issue large overpayments to the IRS in hopes of generating a significant refund. This scheme also failed to generate any sizable refunds from the IRS. Still, in conjunction with Upshur’s first scheme, his actions resulted in an intended-loss figure of $325 million.

After applying the tax loss table set forth by U.S.S.G. § 2T4.1, it was determined that the figure resulted in a base offense level of 34 with certain upward point adjustments being applied because of Upshur’s criminal history. Ultimately, sentencing guidelines suggested a prison sentence between 324 and 328 months. Still, the lower court imposed a lower prison sentence of 84 months.

At the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, Upshur argued that the tax loss figure used to calculate his sentence was improper. He asserted that his actions had actually not caused any loss to the U.S. Treasury. However, on appeal, the Third Circuit upheld the lower court’s decision to use the intended-loss figure to calculate Upshur’s sentence for his tax crimes.

How the IRS Catches Tax Fraud

There are a number of different ways that the IRS catches people who cheat on their taxes. For instance, the following are all common examples of methods the agency employs:

Using Tips from Whistleblowers

The IRS routinely catches tax evaders by using tips from whistleblowers. Whistleblowers are individuals who inform the IRS about illegal activities. There are several reasons why a whistleblower may choose to report certain conduct. For example, a disgruntled employee who wants revenge may issue a report regarding their employer’s improper behavior. Furthermore, the spouse of a criminal tax evader may submit a report to the IRS simply because they want to do the right thing.

IRS Using Computer Analysis to Identify Tax Evaders

The IRS also utilizes a complex computer system that reconciles the information returns submitted by employers and various third parties (W2’s & 1099s) with tax positions reported by individuals on their tax returns. If a discrepancy is identified, then the IRS will investigate the matter further. An audit or criminal tax investigation may be ordered if evidence of potential tax evasion is identified.

Over time, the computer systems used to identify tax evaders have become more sophisticated. If you are concerned that you might be flagged for suspicious activity, then our Dual-Licensed Tax Attorneys & CPAs can help determine the appropriate course of action.

Analyzing Social Media Accounts

Furthermore, the IRS can also use information posted on taxpayers’ social media accounts to identify fraudulent behavior. For example, suppose someone’s public social media posts indicate that they are living a lifestyle that does not coincide with the reported income on their returns. In that case, the government may decide to perform an audit or criminal tax investigation. Still, it is not known whether the IRS can access private communications like emails or nonpublic social media posts.

When Can You Go to Jail for Tax Evasion?

You are not at grave risk of going to prison for simply making minor mistakes on your tax returns. Tax evasion refers to the deliberate underpayment or nonpayment of taxes. Accordingly, in order for you to face criminal penalties for tax evasion, the government must have sufficient evidence to prove that you knowingly and willfully evaded your tax obligations.

There are several potential examples of tax evasion. For instance, an individual may commit tax evasion by purposely underreporting digital assets on their tax returns. Furthermore, an employer may commit tax evasion by paying workers in cash and not issuing W2’s or 1099’s as part of an attempt to evade payroll tax obligations. Finally, people also regularly evade their taxes by failing to report overseas sources of taxable income. Lastly, people commit income tax evasion by understating taxable income, overstating deductions, and claiming credits they are not entitled to.

The U.S. government aggressively enforces tax crimes. The criminal tax penalties imposed against tax evaders can include significant fines and jail time. The average amount of jail time for tax evasion is between three and five years. In general, higher penalties are imposed against those who cause greater tax loss to the government. Still, other factors, such as defendants’ criminal histories, can come into play during sentencing calculations.

Call Our Law Firm for Help Defending Against Allegations of Tax Crimes or Better Yet, to get Right with the Government and Avoid Prosecution Altogether.

If you have failed to file a tax return for one or more years or have taken a position on a tax return that could not be supported upon an IRS or state tax authority audit, eggshell audit, reverse eggshell audit, or criminal tax investigation, it is in your best interest to contact an experienced tax defense attorney to determine your best route back into federal or state tax compliance without facing criminal prosecution.

Note: As long as a taxpayer that has willfully committed tax crimes (potentially including non-filed foreign information returns coupled with affirmative evasion of U.S. income tax on offshore income) self-reports the tax fraud (including a pattern of non-filed returns) through a domestic or offshore voluntary disclosure before the IRS has started an audit or criminal tax investigation / prosecution, the taxpayer can ordinarily be successfully brought back into tax compliance and receive a nearly guaranteed pass on criminal tax prosecution and simultaneously often receive a break on the civil penalties that would otherwise apply.

It is imperative that you hire an experienced and reputable criminal tax defense attorney to take you through the voluntary disclosure process. Only an Attorney has the Attorney Client Privilege and Work Product Privileges that will prevent the very professional that you hire from being potentially being forced to become a witness against you, especially where they prepared the returns that need to be amended, in a subsequent criminal tax audit, investigation or prosecution.

Moreover, only an Attorney can enter you into a voluntary disclosure without engaging in the unauthorized practice of law (a crime in itself). Only an Attorney trained in Criminal Tax Defense fully understands the risks and rewards involved in voluntary disclosures and how to protect you if you do not qualify for a voluntary disclosure.

As uniquely qualified and extensively experienced Criminal Tax Defense Tax Attorneys, Kovel CPAs and EAs, our firm provides a one stop shop to efficiently achieve the optimal and predictable results that simultaneously protect your liberty and your net worth. See our Testimonials to see what our clients have to say about us!

Seek support and guidance from our Dual-Licensed Tax Attorneys & CPAs by calling the Tax Law Offices of David W. Klasing today at (800) 681-1295 or click here to arrange a reduced rate initial consultation.

Questions and Answers for Criminal Tax Representation

Main Office

Orange County

2601 Main St. Penthouse Suite
Irvine, CA 92614

(949) 681-3502

Our headquarters is located in Irvine, CA. Our beautiful 19,700 office space is staffed full-time and always available for our clients to meet with our highly qualified and experienced staff of Attorneys, Certified Public Accountants and Enrolled Agents. We also offer virtual consultations and can travel to meet with clients in one of our satellite offices.

Outside of our 4 hour initial consultation option, we do not charge travel time or travel expenses when traveling to one of our Satellite offices, or surrounding business districts, where it is necessary to meet personally with taxing authority personnel, make court appearances, or any in person meeting deemed necessary for the effective representation of a client. To make this as flexible, efficient, and convenient as possible, David W. Klasing is an Instrument Rated Private Pilot and Utilizes the Firms Cirrus SR22 to service client’s in California and in the Southwest by air. Offices outside these areas are serviced via commercial jet airlines. None of these costs are charged to our clients.

Satellite Offices

California

(310) 492-5583

(760) 338-7035

(916) 290-6625

(415) 287-6568

(909) 991-7557